rose

Brit-Am Versus TG over the Poem "Hebrew Nations"



 Brit-Am 
Research
Revelation
Reconciliation



Brit-Am, Movement of the Ten Tribes, Replies to Some Criticism

TG Returns to the Fray with a Critique on Brit-Am Poetry!

Contents:
Introduction: Brit-Am Note
The Poem: "Hebrew Nations".
Round One.
Criticism by TG of "Hebrew Nations"
Brit-Am Reply to TG
Round Two.




Introduction: Brit-Am Note:

For those of you who do not know, TG, is the pseudonym of one of our more persistent critics.
TG is evidently Jewish and we understand lives in Australia. He is somewhat learned but unfortunately may lack the breadth of spirit needed to appreciate what Brit-Am is about. We have answered his criticisms on several occasions in the past. A few of our best supporters expressed dissatisfaction with our not ignoring TG and his frequent heckling of our lowly being.
The Book of Proverbs deals with this matter.

Proverbs 26:4 Do not answer a fool according to his folly,
    Lest you also be like him.
Proverbs 26:5 Answer a fool according to his folly,
    Lest he be wise in his own eyes.

In other words sometimes one must answer and at other times people like TG should be ignored.
The fact is that TG does on occasion ask pertinent questions giving us an opportunity to answer and elucidate matters that could concern others.
TG in the following letter is referring to our poem, "Hebrew Nations", found on the first page of our web-site on the lower left-hand side.
http://www.britam.org/
Alternately the poem, "Hebrew Nations", may be also seen at:
http://www.britam.org/BAPoetry5.html#Nations





The Poem
Here is the poem:
 

Hebrew Nations
http://www.britam.org/BAPoetry5.html#Nations
Israel is in the center
Tribes are in the West
Joseph is blest
All World gates enter
The very best.
In the far north
Warriors spring forth.
Ends of the earth
Sweden and Denmark
Prove their worth.
To Brit-Am they hark.
Finland and Norway
Canada and the USA
Have their say.
Ireland and Australia
No loss nor failure
South Africa as well
New Zealand is swell.
Britain and Iceland
Belgium and Holland
Numerous as sea-sand
And as stars of sky
To
HaShem they cry
Switzerland repents
And her sin laments.
All these do contain
Lost Hebrew Seed.
Virtue yet to attain
Deep Spiritual Need
Torah still to gain.
Zion is their desire
Souls will be on fire.
With Judah to unite
Heathens to fight.


The Commentary and Criticism of TG are given below and then our own answers follow in the Brit-Am Reply.



Round One
Criticism by TG of "Hebrew Nations"
TG wrote:

Israel is in the center - Gemara [Talmud] to Mishna in Sanhedrin 37a R. Aha Haninah said: Mikra states, Thy navel is like a round goblet ['aggan ha-Sahar] wherein no mingled wine is wanting. 'Thy navel"  that is the Sanhedrin. Why was it called 'navel'?  Because it sat at the navel-point of the world. [Why] 'aggan?10  " Because it protects [meggin] the whole world. - so it is that the Temple was at the centre of the World"

Tribes are in the West - you have yet to prove this
Joseph is blest (blessed) - every tribe was blessed
All World gates enter
The very best. - nonsensical
In the far north
Warriors spring forth. - you mean the Vikings? They were only 'springing' between the late eighth to the early eleventh century, and were highly over-rated due to Christian impressions of them.

Ends of the earth
Sweden and Denmark
Prove their worth. - really? Sweden is not "end of the Earth", even in European mainland Norway has that claim, and Denmark is of course not even close to that claim. What worth do they prove?
 
To Brit-Am they hark. - so there would be lots of Swedes and Danes making contributions to you?
 
Finland and Norway
Canada and the USA
Have their say.
- Ah, here we are! Got many contributors from Finland and Norway?
Ireland and Australia
No loss nor failure
South Africa as well
New Zealand is swell.
- Well, Ireland is touted as one of the PIGS by Italy, though I would say Iceland could just as well be inserted. South Africa is certainly a failure...or will be soon. New Zealand...er, you have never lived in NZ, have you?

Britain and Iceland
Belgium and Holland
Numerous as sea-sand
- sea here is a superfluous word, but Icelanders are certainly very demographically limited and the Dutch also. And Belgians?

And as stars of sky
To
HaShem they cry - they pray to HaShem? Seems to me they are still idol worshipers.

Switzerland repents
And her sin laments.
- this is for hiding all the Nazi gold, or being a tax heaven for Americans? I hadn't heard that the Swiss 'repented' :)

All these do contain
Lost Hebrew Seed.
- so Yair says...but what about the rest?

Virtue yet to attain
Deep Spiritual Need
Torah still to gain.
- its not far, its near...

Zion is their desire - really?
Souls will be on fire.
With Judah to unite
Heathens to fight.
- maybe you should rename the new journal The New Crusader? It goes to the core of your misunderstanding of Torah. We are not about fighting heathen.

You know Yair that poetry is a difficult form of literature. Some poets spend months on a single poem that barely fills a page. And this is people with a talent. And, they have friends and editors to show their output to who can reflect on the verses, and perhaps suggest improvement of offer constructive criticism. Of course you object to any criticism what's so ever...
TG





Brit-Am Reply to TG:

TG quotes the Talmud saying the Temple site is at the center of the World. Fair enough, it is. Last I heard the Temple Site is in Jerusalem in the Land of Israel which is what we intended.
We have proven that the Lost Ten Tribes are amongst Western Nations. Anyone who disagrees should bring proofs of their own and not simply express disagreement.
Every Tribes blest: Joseph was blessed more than the other Tribes.

[Genesis 48:20] AND HE BLESSED THEM THAT DAY, SAYING, IN THEE SHALL ISRAEL BLESS, SAYING, GOD MAKE THEE AS EPHRAIM AND AS MANASSEH: AND HE SET EPHRAIM BEFORE MANASSEH.

Nations identified by Brit-Am as the Lost Ten Tribes were the best in the world as far as quality of life and other parameters are concerned. They are the peoples that all other nations would like to emulate.

The Vikings emerged from Scandinavia in the 700s-900s CE. They terrorized Ireland, Scotland, Wales, England, and other places whose populations themselves had formidable fighting reputations. They held the Carolingian Empire (i.e. the major world power at the time) at bay and forced it to cede them the territory of Normandy in West France. During the Viking Era, in every generation ca. 20% of Scandinavinan males died fighting. Viking mercenaries kept the Byzantine Emperors (of the eastern Roman Empire, also a major World Power in that age) on the throne and helped them govern their Empire. Viking adventurers conquered Russian tribes and founded the kingdom of Russia. The Norman descendants of the Vikings conquered England, Sicily, and southern Italy. They intermixed with the Irish and Scottish nobility and participated in their perpetual internecine warfare. They were also prominent in the Crusades. Afterwards during the Thirty Years War (1618-1648) Swedish armies were quite prominent in Germany.

# Sweden conquered approximately half of the Holy Roman states.#

Swedes rampaged all over Europe.
For peoples whose population was always relatively small compared to that of other nations these achievements may well be considered those of  warrior peoples.
Scandinavian nations are known in history for their Vikings and in recent times for their relatively successful welfare-orientated societies. They have enjoyed comparatively high standards of living while contributing to world scientific, technical and cultural achievements.

Sweden, Denmark, and Norway may all be considered "ends of the earth" in so far as they are adjuncts (i.e. "ends") to the European Continental Land mass.
"Large numbers" of Scandinavians do not support Brit-Am, Movement of the Ten Tribes. They do support the Palestinian Arabs and give large sums of money to Quisling NGO groups in Israel that work to undermine the Jewish-Israelite character of the State of Israel. They in effect support the enemies of the Jewish People who are also their enemies. If they knew what they should do they would indeed support us instead. They should be supporting Brit-Am but they are not. Nevertheless we do have a few individual supporters amongst them who quality wise are much valued by us.

We would advice TG not to be concerned with who does and who does not contribute to Brit-Am. Since he is not a supporter of ours, it is none of his business. I am sure he has his own problems to worry about.

TG refers to the economic straits of Ireland, South Africa, and New Zealand.
Until recently Ireland statistically had one of the highest qualities of living in the world or was close to it. South Africa for a long period was also blessed until the control of the British-descended and the Boers was terminated. New Zealand statistically may not be in the best of shape but for a good while it was considered a place whose inhabitants were well of in terms of agricultural produce, raw materials, health standards, citizens rights, etc., alongside the beauty of its scenery and  its salubrious environment. It was a place people in the west dreamt of holidaying in or retiring to. The movie series "Lord of the Ring" (based on the stories by Tolkien)  was filmed in New Zealand.

Demographic:
There are 317,000 people in Iceland, 16, 500, 000 in the Netherlands (of whom ca.80% are ethnic Dutch), 10.7 million in Belgium.
By way of comparison there are an estimated 12 to 14 million Jews in the world today.
What was the point TG made about demography?

Our poem was just that, a poem. It was not intended as an encyclopedia entry. Poetry allows for the expression of hope and the paraphrasing of Prophecy.
At some time in the future the Ten Tribes of Israel will repent. How and when this will happen we do not know.
If you disagree with us then it is not us with whom you are in conflict but rather with Scripture.

TG remarked:
# We are not about fighting heathen. #
This is true.
Maimonides ("Laws of Kings and their Wars" 12.4) said:
# The Prophets and Sages did not yearn for the Messianic Era in order to rule over all the world; and not to govern the Gentiles;  and not so that the nations should elevate them; and not in order to eat, drink and be happy; but rather in order to free to learn the Torah...#

Nevertheless, even though fighting other peoples and ruling over them may not be the goal of the whole arrangement it will be an accompaniment to it or at least to the events preceding it.
This is what the Prophets say. Isaiah relates how Judah and Joseph shall expel the Palestinians from the Land of Israel and fly them to another location and how together they shall defeat Ammon, Moab, and Edom, and the Children of the East and rule over them.
See:
The Brit-Am Commentary to Isaiah chapter 11.
http://www.britam.org/isaiah/Isaiah11to15.html#11

TG mentions our inadequacy in the handling of Poetry.
Our poems are our own. Their purpose is to present our teachings in a format that is interesting and entertaining.
They do not have to be exemplary.




Round Two
Glutton for Punishment

 

TG wrote:
 

Yair, you are so disingenuous!

I wrote the response months ago, but you clearly don't get much response from anyone else, so opt to 'flog a dead horse'!


Brit-Am Answers:
We did not intend to flog you.

We also do not really consider you a dead horse.
The Talmud (that you like to quote from) says, One should not denigrate oneself. So why do you do it?
As for yourself:  We do not really need a volunteer to serve as our punching bag but you keep insisting.
 

TG wrote:

Who are these "few of our best supporters"? Probably two or three people as confused and ignorant as you are.

Brit-Am Answers:
Everything is relative. Concerning the Lost Ten Tribes and Biblical Understanding of this issue we are still light years ahead of types like yourself.

TG wrote:
Do you know what the Talmud is? I seem to doubt it since you hardly ever, EVER quote from it, but I suggest you look up what Rab Yehuda ben Rab Shmuel bar Shilat said about these verses in Proverbs in Shabbat 30b

Brit-Am Answers:
We do not quote that often from the Talmud since we are not promoting Judaism but rather awareness as to the identity of the Ten Tribes. We also work to intensify Biblical Consciousness in general. The Talmud pertains more to Judah and to internal Jewish matters as the Sages themselves emphasized.
You quoted from the Talmud on,
Proverbs 26:4 Do not answer a fool according to his folly, Lest you also be like him.
Proverbs 26:5 Answer a fool according to his folly, Lest he be wise in his own eyes.

The source you mentioned (Talmud, Shabat 30b) resolves the apparent contradiction by saying that a fool should be answered when the question involves matters of the Torah and not answered when it concerns general issues.
Which category do you fit into?
Apart from that, sometimes the Talmud gives general advice (that is not necessarily applicable in every instance and may be accepted or rejected at one's own discretion) and sometimes it lays down the Law.
Read the Commentaries.

The source you quote from says nothing really pertinent to the present discussion. You evidently do not read our postings that often. There are reasons for everything we do and how we do it. The Talmud itself along with the major commentaries emphasizes that several explanations are possible for each Biblical Passage. One does not contradict the other, see Sanhedrin 34.a

TG quotes from Brit-Am:
Brit-Am Reply:
TG quotes the Talmud saying the Temple site is at the center of the World. Fair enough, it is. Last I heard the Temple Site is in Jerusalem in the Land of Israel which is what we intended.


TG comments:
What *you" intended?! Maybe HaShem intended?
Yet again you prove that you have 0 analytical thought capability. If Israel is at the centre, then the position of the tribes around it is going to be same as before exile, i.e. around it. Therefore the 'lost' tribes are not JUST in the West, but all around Israel. Think about it.
However, the
Talmud have a lot more to say about this that you are seemingly ignorant of.


Brit-Am Replies:
The Tribes were not around the Temple. The Temple was in Judah in the south. Most Tribes were to the North. The Tribes  were around the Mishcan (Tabernacle) in the Wilderness.
In our book "The Tribes" we show how today the relative positioning of the Ten Tribes to each other is similar to that they once had both in the Wilderness around the Tabernacle and when they were in the Land of Israel. Their positioning in regards to Judah (the present-day Land of Israel) is also similar to some degree.

TG quotes from Brit-Am:
We have proven that the Lost ten Tribes are amongst Western Nations. Anyone who disagrees should bring proofs of their own and not simply express disagreement.

Every Tribes blest. Joseph was blessed more than the other Tribes.


TG says:
You just want me to do your work for you and spoon-feed you the information. Not going to happen. I don't have to prove anything to you.

Brit-Am Replies:
Yes you do have to prove what you say, the same as we do.
You argue with us, say we are wrong. We bring proofs and evidence saying that concerning the Ten Tribes we are right. If you do not wish to relate to our argumentation, do not do so. You cannot however tell us we are wrong without saying why.
 

TG quotes from Brit-Am:


..... during the Thirty Years War (1618-1648) Swedish armies were quite prominent in Germany.

TG says:
 

More cut-and-pasting lol


Brit-Am says:
There is hardly any cut and pasting here, but what if there was? Either it is right or it is not.

TG says:
 

No, the Vikings did not emerge from Scandinavia, and they did not terrorize Ireland, Scotland, Wales, England, and other places...and by the way the House of Rurik from which begins the formation of the Rus and Russian Empire was founded by Swedes, but did not conquer the Russian tribes since there were no 'Russian' tribes at the time, and the Slav tribes were ranging from the Oder in the West to the Urals in the East and from the Baltic in the North to the Dnepr in the South. Viking simply means 'expeditionary' and vikingr means a participant in one. In those days there was no Scandinavia of course. Norman is just another name for the people who came from the North, and strictly speaking not synonymous with Vikings which describes a type of activity (expeditionary) not a region of origin. Had you understood this, you would never make such an outlandish claim that "Vikings conquered England, Sicily, and southern Italy". And of course since Swedes, Danes and Norwegians. Hardly any 'scandinavians' participated in the initial crusades because they were not really Christian until early 13th century despite introduction of that religion in the 11th century...and there was the actual distance.
Normandy is in the North of France, not West.

Brit-Am says:
You are using semantics to obscure the facts. Your history is wrong.
Scandinavia is a geographic term. Viking is a historical one. The people known to historians as Vikings emerged from the area known in geography as Scandinavia. Slavic Tribes that were ancestral to the Russian peoples were conquered and amalgamated by the Viking-associated Rus. Normans from England and from Normandy were prominent in the Crusades. Normandy is both in the north and west of France. At that time the term "France" applied more to the northern region. The Normans who settled in Normandy were Vikings from Norway and Denmark.
The whole point of what we were discussing is the question of warriors emerging from Scandinavia. Whether one refers to them as Vikings or anything else is not really pertinent to the discussion.

TG quotes from Brit-Am and comments:
 

# Sweden conquered approximately half of the Holy Roman states.#

Are you so arrogant as to even ignore such mundane sources of information as Wikipedia?


Brit-Am Replies:
That was a quote from Wikipedia.
Go to:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sweden
Scroll down to the heading:
Swedish Empire
The second paragraph down begins with the sentence:
# During the Thirty Years' War, Sweden conquered approximately half of the Holy Roman states. #
It continues:
# Gustav Adolphus planned to become the new Holy Roman Emperor, ruling over a united Scandinavia and the Holy Roman states, but he died at the Battle of Lozen in 1632. After the Battle of Nedlingen, Sweden's only significant military defeat of the war, pro-Swedish sentiment among the German states faded. These German provinces excluded themselves from Swedish power one by one, leaving Sweden with only a few northern German territories: Swedish Pomerania, Bremen-Verden and Wismar. The Swedish armies may have destroyed up to 2,000 castles, 18,000 villages and 1,500 towns in Germany, one-third of all German towns.[32].
In the middle of the 17th century Sweden was the third largest country in Europe by land area, only surpassed by Russia and Spain. Sweden reached its largest territorial extent under the rule of Charles X after the treaty of
Roskilde in 1658.[33][34] #

TG said:
 

 The Swedish Empire at its zenith in 1658 barely had a toe-hold in continental Europe aside from the current Baltic republics territories. Do you even know where the Holy Roman Empire was?

Brit-Am Replies:
Your facts are wrong. See the quote above.
During the Thirty Years War and afterwards Swedish troops rampaged throughout Germany that comprised much of what was then left of the Holy Roman Empire. Sweden ruled over Finland, and the Baltic area. Sweden also invaded Poland, Lithuania, and Russia.
I repeat the point of the argument here is whether or not warriors of world renown emerged from Scandinavia during and after the Viking Era. The history of Sweden shows that they did. Sweden was a world power. Swedish armies fought against and defeated the forces of Continental Europe. Point made.

TG said:
And where do you get the idea that Haza"l [the Sages] was talking about the European Continental Landmass?!

Brit-Am Replies:
Who said anything about Haza"l? We were quoting from the Bible,
see,
Ends of the Earth
http://britam.org/Proof/geo/geoEnds.html.

 TG quotes from Brit-Am and comments:
"Large numbers" of Scandinavians do not support Brit-Am....If they knew what they should do they would indeed support us instead.

do, or would? are you prophesying now? :)

Brit-Am Replies:
We work on behalf of the Lost Ten Tribes of Israel. This includes a significant portion of the populations of Scandinavia. We believe that in some way we are of service to them and we are in need of funding. They have funds that they give out to our mutual enemies. They should help us and people like us instead. What is the problem with what we were saying?

  TG quotes from Brit-Am and comments:
South Africa for a long period was also blessed until the control of British and Boers was terminated.

Blessed? If not for the gold and diamonds, it would have been a total drain on the British Empire like its other colonies. Look at it now.
Brit-Am Replies:
If not for this, if not for that. Who cares? The fact is that it was a blessing. The Possession of gold and diamonds was a part of that blessing.
It had been prophesied as part of the blessing to Joseph and Israel:
BY THE ALMIGHTY, WHO SHALL BLESS THEE WITH ...BLESSINGS OF THE DEEP THAT LIETH UNDER [Genesis 49:25]
See:
Vast Mineral Resources.

TG quotes from Brit-Am and comments:

 New Zealand statistically may not be in the best of shape but for a good while it was considered a place whose inhabitants were well of in terms of agricultural produce, raw materials, health standards, citizens rights, etc.

Do you even know anything about NZ?

Brit-Am Replies:
If you think we are lacking in our knowledge of NZ go ahead and enlighten us. Evidently you do not think much of New Zealand?

TG quotes from Brit-Am and comments:

There are 317,000 people in Iceland, 16, 500, 000 in the Netherlands (of whom ca.80% are ethnic Dutch), 10.7 million in Belgium.
By way of comparison there are an estimated 12 to 14 million Jews in the world today.
What was your point about demography?


Look up Haza"l. Belgians are  of the same genetic stock as the rest of the migrant Europeans, and that includes Slavs and even some Turks.

Our poem was just that, a poem....

I get annoyed by how you refer to yourself in the plural...

Brit-Am Replies:
As we have said before. If only because it annoys types like yourself this practice of ours has its advantages.

TG quotes from Brit-Am and comments:

....TG mentions our inadequacy in the handling of Poetry.
Our poems are our own. Their purpose is to present our teachings in a format that is interesting and entertaining.
They do not have to be exemplary.

do you pray from a kosher siddur [Jewish Prayer Book]?
Have you seen the poems there?
Yes, when you write a poem that mentions Israel it has to be exemplary, though I note that your poems do mention
HaShem...where as Europeans 'cry' largely to the EU Parliament now, and sometimes still to [the Christian Messiah]:)
Brit-Am Replies:
The Siddur and the Tanaach (Hebrew Bible) are full of poetry. That however is not their main task. We admit that we are not up to their standard but neither is anybody else.

Brit-Am Biblical Proofs provide evidence that the Lost Ten Tribes are amongst Western Peoples. This is confirmed by Rabbinical and Secular Sources. You disagree and express your disagreement but you fail to explain why.
We are disappointed by the general lack of erudition and sophistication displayed by our opponents. You are indeed (as you yourself suggested) hardly worth replying to.
The Lost Ten Tribes are amongst Western Peoples. This is a fact. It needs to be dealt with. Other questions arise from this fact.

Site Contents by Subject Home
Research
Revelation
Reconciliation
Books
Magazine
Publications
Site Map
Contents in Alphabetical Order

rose
Contribute

Search
This Site







Join the Brit-Am Ephraimite Discussion Group
Just Send an
e-mail
with "Subscribe"
in the Subject Line

Main Page

Offerings and Publications