Brit-Am Discussion Group |
Contents by Subject |
Research Recognition Reconciliation Contribute |
Site Map Contents in Alphabetical Order |
This Site |
Turkey's role in aiding and abetting the flotilla, and its subsequent
anti-Israeli outbursts, were excessive even by the often sick standards of the
Middle East, but not exactly new. State-run Turkish television has aired
virulent anti-Semitic dramas like the 2006 Valley of the Wolves, in which a
Jewish doctor harvests organs from captured Iraqi civilians.
Anti-Semitism as displayed by both Thomas and Turkey's leaders is not predicated
on criticizing Israel, much less disagreeing with its foreign policy. Instead,
it hinges upon focusing singularly on Israeli behavior, and applying a standard
to it that is never extended to any other nation.
There are plenty of disputes over borders and land in the world. But to Helen
Thomas or the Turkish government, Kashmir or the Russian-Chinese border matters
little, although the chances of escalation to nuclear confrontation are far
greater there than on the West Bank.... The Palestinian "refugees", a majority
of whom are the children, grandchildren, or great-grandchildren of people
actually displaced in 1948, compose a small part of the world's refugee
population. There are millions of refugees in Rwanda, the Congo, and Darfur.
Well over a half-million Jews were ethnically cleansed from the major Arab
capitals between 1947 and 1973, each wave of expulsion cresting after a
particular Mideast war. Again, few care to demonstrate for the plight of any of
these people. Prime Minister Erdogan has not led any global effort to relocate
the starving millions in Darfur, despite his loud concern for "refugees" in
Gaza. ...Few worry that in 1949 tens of thousands of Japanese were
forcibly expelled by the Soviet Union from Sakhalin
Island.
The world likewise cares little for the concept of "occupation" in the abstract;
it is only the concrete example of Palestine that earns its opprobrium. We can
be assured that President Obama will not bring up Ossetia with President Putin.
He will not raise the question of Tibet with the Chinese or occupied Cyprus with
Prime Minister Erdogan. Will Helen Thomas ever ask, "How can Turkey be allowed
to keep Nicosia a divided city?" Will she worry whether Greeks are allowed to
buy property in the Turkish sector of that capital?
...The United Nations is angrier at Israel for enforcing a blockade against its
terrorist neighbor than it is at Somalia for allowing pirates to kill and rob
right off its coast. There was not much of a global outcry when Iran hijacked a
British naval vessel; few in Turkey demonstrated when the French blew up a
Greenpeace protest vessel. "Disproportionate" is a term used to condemn Israeli
retaliation. It does not apply to other, far more violent reprisals, such as the
Russian leveling of Grozny, or the Turkish killing of Kurds, or occasional Hindu
mass rioting and murdering of Muslims in India. Does Prime Minister Erdogan wish
to allow "peace activists" to interview Kurds detained in his prisons, or to
adjudicate the status of Kurds, Armenians, or Christian religious figures who
live in Turkey?
Can we imagine a peace flotilla of Swedish and British leftists sailing to Cyprus to "liberate" Greek land or investigate the "disappearance" of thousands of Greeks in 1974? And if they did, what would happen to them? About the same as would happen if they blocked a road to interdict a Turkish armored column rolling into Kurdistan.
Nor do human-rights violations mean much any more. Iran executes more of its own
citizens each year than Israel has killed Palestinians in the course of war in
any given year. Syria murders whomever it pleases in Lebanon without worry that
any international body will ever condemn its action. I have heard a great deal
about the "massacre" or "slaughter" at Jenin, where 52 Palestinians and 23
Israelis died. Indeed, the 2002 propaganda film Jenin, Jenin was a big hit on
college campuses. But I have never seen a documentary Hama, Hama commemorating
the real 1982 slaughter of somewhere between 10,000 and 40,000 civilians by the
criminal Assad regime in Syria, with which we now so eagerly wish to restore
ties. I find a 1,000-to-1 fatality rule generally applies:
Each person killed by the Israel Defense Forces warrants about as much international attention as 1,000 people killed by Africans, Russians, Indians, Chinese, or Arabs.
I used to think that oil, Arab demography, fear of Islamic terrorism, and
blowback from its close association with the United States explained the global
double standard that is applied to Israel. But after the hysteria over the Gaza
flotilla, the outbursts of various members of the Turkish government, and Ms.
Thomas's candid revelations, I think the mad-dog hatred of Israel is more or
less because it is a Jewish state.
Period.
Let me explain. Intellectuals used to loudly condemn anti-Semitism because it
was largely associated with those deemed to be less sophisticated people, often
right-wing, who on either racial, nationalistic, or religious grounds regarded
Jews as undesirable. Hating Jews was a sign of boorish chauvinism, or of the
conspiratorial mind that exuded envy and jealousy of the more successful. But in
the last two decades especially, the Left has made anti-Semitism respectable in
intellectual circles. The fascistic nature of various Palestinian liberation
groups was forgotten, as the "occupied" Palestinians grafted their cause onto
that of American blacks, Mexican-Americans, and Asian-Americans. Slurring
post-Holocaust Jews was still infra dig, but damning the nation-state of Israel
as imperialistic and oppressive was considered principled. No one ever cared to
ask: Why Israel and not other, far more egregious examples? In other words, one
could now focus inordinately on the Jews by emphasizing that one's criticism was
predicated on cosmic issues of human rights and justice. And by defaming Israel
the nation, one could vent one's dislike of Jews without being stuck with the
traditional boorish label of anti-Semite. ...
(http://www.uc4i.org/news/?p=5588)
Pleased with what you read'
Click Here to make an offering. |
PREVIOUS ISSUES |
|
|