|
Brit-Am Discussion Group |
Contents by Subject |
Research Recognition Reconciliation Contribute |
Site Map Contents in Alphabetical Order |
This Site |
##Jews apparently can't ride elevators on the Sabbath because pushing a button breaks the Sabbath....Such beliefs are pure nonsense to most of us. ##
Reply:
Initially we answered:
If you are not
Jewish you are not obligated by the Law so you can ride in the elevator on a
Saturday with a clear conscience. All day long if you like.
We now feel that this answer may have been somewhat unnecessarily caustic.
Electricity and the widespread use of electric appliances etc is a comparatively
recent phenomenon. When this usage was introduced and became widespread
Rabbinical Opinion was divided. There were some authorities who permitted it.
Eventually a consensus was reached whereby it was decided (in simplified terms)
that electricity on Sabbath would be allowed but initiating the process by
turning on a switch etc forbidden. This, roughly speaking, is the Jewish law
today in Rabbinical Orthodox circles.
The Conservative and Reform Jewish religions officially apparently deny the
Divine Origin of the Torah. There were, and still are, however maverick "Rabbis"
amongst them who try to maintain some semblance of Jewish Legal ("halachic")
legitimacy. In cases such as electricity on Sabbath etc they will quote the
lenient opinions that some Rabbis once held before the contrary stricter view
was universally accepted. For non-Jews who do not wish to become Jewish but wish
to keep the Law without making it too burdensome on themselves such lenient
rulings could be an option?
Pleased with what you read?
Click Here to make an offering. |
PREVIOUS ISSUES |
|
|